Lesson 4: Comparing Proportional Relationships

Let’s compare proportional relationships.

4.1: What's the Relationship?

The equation y=4.2x could represent a variety of different situations.

  1. Write a description of a situation represented by this equation. Decide what quantities x and y represent in your situation.

  2. Make a table and a graph that represent the situation.

4.2: Comparing Two Different Representations

  1. Elena babysits her neighbor’s children. Her earnings are given by the equation y=8.40x, where x represents the number of hours she worked and y represents the amount of money she earned. Jada earns $7 per hour mowing her neighbors’ lawns.
    1. Who makes more money after working 12 hours? How much more do they make? Explain how you know.
    2. What is the rate of change for each situation and what does it mean?  
    3. How long would it take each person to earn $150? Explain or show your reasoning.
  2. Clare and Han have summer jobs stuffing envelopes for two different companies.

    Clare’s earnings can be seen in the table.

    Han earns $15 for every 300 envelopes he finishes.

      number of envelopes money in dollars
    row 1 400 40
    row 2 900 90
    1. Who would make more money after stuffing 1500 envelopes? How much more money would they make? Explain how you know.  
    2. What is the rate of change for each situation and what does it mean?
    3. Who gets paid more in their job? Explain or show your reasoning.
  3. Tyler plans to start a lemonade stand and is trying to perfect his recipe for lemonade. He wants to make sure the recipe doesn’t use too much lemonade mix (lemon juice and sugar) but still tastes good.
    Lemonade Recipe 1 is given by the equation y=4x where x represents the amount of lemonade mix in cups and y represents the amount of water in cups.
    Lemonade Recipe 2 is given in the table.
      lemonade mix (cups) water (cups)
    row 1 10 50
    row 2 13 65
    row 3 21 105
    1. If Tyler had 16 cups of lemonade mix, how many cups of water would he need for each recipe? Explain how you know.
    2. What is the rate of change for each situation and what does it mean?  
    3. Tyler has a 5-gallon jug (which holds 80 cups) to use for his lemonade stand and 16 cups of lemonade mix. Which lemonade recipe should he use? Explain or show your reasoning.

Summary

When two proportional relationships are represented in different ways, we compare them by finding a common piece of information.

For example, Clare’s earnings are represented by the equation y=14.5x, where y is her earnings in dollars for working x hours.

The table shows some information about Jada’s pay.

Who is paid at a higher rate per hour? How much more does that person have after 20 hours?

  time worked (hours) earnings (dollars)
row 1 7 92.75
row 2 4.5 59.63
row 3 37 490.25

In Clare’s equation we see that the constant of proportionality relating her earnings to time worked is 14.50. This means that she earns $14.50 per hour.

We can calculate Jada’s constant of proportionality by dividing a value in the earnings column by a value in the same row in the time worked column. Using the last row, the constant of proportionality for Jada is 13.25, since 490.25\div37=13.25. An equation representing Jada’s earnings is y=13.25x. This means she earns $13.25 per hour.

So Clare is paid at a higher rate than Jada. Clare earns $1.25 more per hour than Jada, which means that after 20 hours of work, she has 20\boldcdot \$1.25 = \$25 more than Jada.

Practice Problems ▶